Hong Kong department weighs appeal over engineer’s hospital lift sentence

Hong Kong’s Electrical and Mechanical Services Department is seeking legal advice on whether to challenge a non-custodial sentence imposed on lift engineer Law Wing-chai. The engineer was held responsible for issuing false safety certifications and failing to identify problems linked to malfunctions at Queen Mary Hospital’s new clinical block.
Hong Kong’s Electrical and Mechanical Services Department is considering an appeal against the non-custodial sentence imposed on an engineer held liable for faulty lift installation work at Queen Mary Hospital’s new clinical block. The department said on Thursday that it was seeking legal advice on whether to apply for a review of lift engineer Law Wing-chai’s sentence. According to the department, Law was deemed responsible for issuing false safety certifications and for failing to identify problems that later led to lift malfunctions.
The supplied information does not state the exact sentence imposed, the court involved or when the malfunctions occurred. The department’s review will determine whether there are grounds to challenge the sentence. No decision to appeal has been reported, and the department has not indicated what alternative penalty it might seek.
The case concerns the installation and certification of lifts at the hospital’s new clinical block. The available material does not provide further details about the number of lifts affected, the nature of the faults or whether anyone was injured. The department’s decision is therefore pending legal advice.
Until that process is complete, the engineer’s non-custodial sentence remains the outcome described in the source material.
This independently written report is based on information supplied by the named publisher. Vertrix News has not independently verified the source report.